YU Chao;

• 1:School of Marxism
• 2: Wuhan University
• 3:Hubei Collaborative Innovation Center for Marxist Theory and China's Practice
• 4: Wuhan University

Abstract：

This article systematically examines the history of economic thought on how rent affects economic growth from the perspective of Marxist economics. When Marx constructed the reproduction model, there were two theoretical “gaps” due to the lack of consideration for the international transfer of imperialist rent and the role of productive investment in domestic rent in economic growth. The theories of imperialism and underdevelopment analyze the heterogeneous effects of imperialist rent on economic growth in developed and underdeveloped countries, thus achieving a “replenishment” in the first dimension. Socialist political economy analyzes the productive investment of rent to achieve the strategic catch-up of the socialist economy, while urban political economy interprets the financialization of real estate leads to the decline of the capitalist economy, thus achieving a “replenishment” in the second dimension. The above theoretical viewpoints have deepened the connection between the theory of reproduction and the theory of rent, not only connecting the second and third volumes of Capital, but also filling in some parts of Marx's six-volume plan to a certain extent, thus further improving and developing the theoretical system of Marxist economics.

Key Words： rent;imperialism theory;underdeveloped theory;socialism political economy;urban political economy

Abstract:

Keywords:

Foundation: 国家社会科学基金青年项目“马克思主义视域下租金对经济增长与收入分配的作用机制研究”(批准号:24CJL001)的阶段性成果

Authors: YU Chao;

References：

• 阿吉里·伊曼纽尔.1988.不平等交换：对帝国主义贸易的研究[M].文贯中，译.北京：中国对外经济贸易出版社.(original language) EMMANUEL A.1972.Unequal exchange:A study of the imperialist of trade[M].London:Monthly Review Press. 安德烈·弗兰克.1984.不发达的发展[M]//查尔斯·威尔伯.发达与不发达问题的政治经济学.高铦，译.北京：中国社会科学出版社.(original language) FRANK A.[1966].Underdeveloped development[J].Monthly Review,18(4):17-31. 保罗·巴兰.1984.论落后问题的政治经济学[M]//查尔斯·威尔伯.发达与不发达问题的政治经济学.高铦，译.北京：中国社会科学出版社.(original language) BARAN P.[1952].On the political economy of backwardness[J].The Manchester School,20(1):66-84. 陈岱孙.2014.从古典经济学派到马克思——若干主要学说发展论略[M].北京：商务印书馆.CHEN D S.2014.From the classical school of economics to Marx:A brief discussion on the development of several major theories[M].Beijing:The Commercial Press.(in Chinese) 程恩富，鲁保林，俞使超.2019.论新帝国主义的五大特征和特性——以列宁的帝国主义理论为基础[J].马克思主义研究，(5):49-65,159-160.CHENG E F,LU B L,YU S C.2019.Five characteristics and features of neo-imperialism—An analysis based on Lenin's imperialism theory[J].Studies on Marxism,(5):49-65,159-160.(in Chinese) 大卫·哈维.2019.新帝国主义[M].付克新，译.北京：中国人民大学出版社.(original language) HARVEY D.2004.The New Imperialism[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press. 道格拉斯·诺思.1994.经济史中的结构与变迁[M].陈郁，罗华平，译.上海：上海人民出版社.(original language) NORTH D C.1981.Structure and change in economic history[M].New York:W.W.Norton & Company,Inc. 董筱丹.2015.再读苏南：苏州工业园区二十年发展述要[M].苏州：苏州大学出版社.DONG X D.2015.Rereading Su Nan:A summary of the development of Suzhou industrial park in the past 20 years[M].Suzhou:Soochow University Press.(in Chinese) 韩兆洲.1993.工农业产品价格剪刀差的计量方法研究[J].统计研究，(1):49-51.HAN Z Z.1993.Research on the measurement method of scissor difference in industrial and agricultural product prices[J].Statistical Research,(1):49-51.(in Chinese) 蒋省三，刘守英，李青.2007.土地制度改革与国民经济成长[J].管理世界，(9):1-9.JIANG S S,LIU S Y,LI Q.2007.The land system reform and the growth of the national economy[J].Journal of Management World,(9):1-9.(in Chinese) 卡勒姆·沃德，曼努埃尔·奥尔伯斯.2022.“地租这个烂摊子”:地租理论的意义何在?[J].政治经济学报，22(1):137-162.WARD C,AALBERS M.2022.“Virtual special issue editorial essay:‘The shitty rent business’:What's the point of land rent theory?”[J].The Chinese Journal of Political Economy,22(1):137-162. 李春林，天舒.1998.中国汽车产业发展问题报告[M].沈阳：沈阳出版社.LI C L,TIAN S.1998.Report on development issues of China's automotive industry[M].Shenyang:Shenyang Publishing House.(in Chinese) 李连波，黄泽清.2021.住房金融化与《论住宅问题》的时代价值[J].当代经济研究，(4):16-26.LI L B,HUANG Z Q.2021.Housing financialization and the contemporary value of the housing question[J].Contemporary Economic Research,(4):16-26.(in Chinese) 列宁.2014.帝国主义是资本主义的最高阶段[M].中共中央马克思恩格斯列宁斯大林著作编译局，译.北京：人民出版社：60. 刘守英.2018.土地制度变革与经济结构转型——对中国40年发展经验的一个经济解释[J].中国土地科学，32(1):1-10.LIU S Y.2018.Land institutional reform and structural transformation in China:An economic interpretation for China's 40 years development experience[J].China Land Science,32(1):1-10.(in Chinese) 鲁道夫·希法亭.1994.金融资本[M].福民，译.北京：商务印书馆.(original language) HIFERDING R.1968.Das finanzkapital[M].Frankfurt:Europ??ische Verlagsanstalt. 马克思，恩格斯.2009a.马克思恩格斯文集(第7卷)[M].中共中央马克思恩格斯列宁斯大林著作编译局，译.北京：人民出版社. 马克思，恩格斯.2009b.马克思恩格斯文集(第5卷)[M].中共中央马克思恩格斯列宁斯大林著作编译局，译.北京：人民出版社. 马克思，恩格斯.2009c.马克思恩格斯文集(第6卷)[M].中共中央马克思恩格斯列宁斯大林著作编译局，译.北京：人民出版社. 马克思，恩格斯.2009d.马克思恩格斯文集(第10卷)[M].中共中央马克思恩格斯列宁斯大林著作编译局，译.北京：人民出版社. 迈克尔·赫德森.2008.金融帝国：美国金融霸权的来源和基础[M].嵇飞，林小芳，译.北京：中央编译出版社.(original language) HUDSON M.2003.Super imperialism.The origin and fundamentals of U.S.world dominance[M].London:Pluto Press. 迈克尔·赫德森.2010.从马克思到高盛：虚拟资本的幻想和产业的金融化 (上)[J].国外理论动态，2010,(9):1-9,71.HUDSON M.2010.From Marx to Goldman sachs:The illusion of virtual capital and the financialization of industries.Foreign Theoretical Trends,(9):1-9,71.(in Chinese) 迈克尔·霍华德，约翰·金.2003.马克思主义经济学史1929—1990[M].北京：中央编译出版社.(original language) HOWARD M C,KING J E.1992.A history of Marxian economics volume Ⅱ,1929—1990[M].London:Red Globe Press. 孟捷，龚剑.2014.金融资本与“阶级—垄断地租”——哈维对资本主义都市化的制度分析[J].中国社会科学，(8):91-108.MENG J,GONG J.2014.Financial capital and “class monopoly land rent”—Harvey's institutional analysis of capitalist urbanization[J].Social Sciences in China,(8):91-108.(in Chinese) 孟捷，吴丰华.2020.制度-垄断地租与中国地方政府竞争：一个马克思主义分析框架[J].开放时代，(2):160-179,9.MENG J,WU F H.2020.The institution-monopoly rent and competition between local governments in China:A marxist framework of analysis[J].Open Times,(2):160-179,9.(in Chinese) 尼古拉·伊万诺维奇·布哈林.1981.布哈林文选中册[M].国际共运史研究室，译.北京：人民出版社.BUKHARIN N.1981.Selected works of Bukharin[M].International Communist Movement History Research Room,trans.Beijing:People's Publishing House.(in Chinese) 普列奥布拉任斯基.1984.新经济学[M].纪涛，蔡恺民，译.北京：三联书店.(original language) ПРЕОБРАЖЕНСКИЙ.1926.Новая экономика[M].Советское коммунистическое издательство. 齐昊.2008.马克思主义的不平等交换理论与中国对外贸易的现实[J].政治经济学评论，2008(1):64-85.QI H.2008.Marxist' theories on inequality and foreign trade of China[J].Review of Political Economy,2008(1):64-85.(in Chinese) 齐昊，问严锴.2021.绝对地租的形成机制：理论评析与当代意义[J].教学与研究，(4):44-54.QI H,WEN Y K.2021.The formation mechanism of absolute land rent:Theoretical evaluation and contemporary significance[J].Teaching and Research,(4):44-54.(in Chinese) 汤在新.1992.从经济学手稿到《资本论》[J].中国社会科学，(5):95-112.TANG Z X.1992.From economic manuscripts to capital[J].Social Sciences in China,(5):95-112.(in Chinese) 吴德荣.2010.租金的生产与中国的产业发展[M]//巫永平，吴德荣.寻租与中国产业发展.北京：商务印书馆.WU D R.2010.Rent production and industrial development in China[M]//WU Y P,WU D R.Rent Seeking and Industrial Development in China.Beijing:The Commercial Press.(in Chinese) 吴易风.2007.马克思的经济增长理论模型[J].经济研究，42(9):11-17,48.WU Y F.2007.Marx's model of economic growth theory[J].Economic Research Journal,42(9):11-17,48.(in Chinese) 巫永平.2010.地方政府、寻租与产业政策[M]//巫永平，吴德荣.寻租与中国产业发展.北京：商务印书馆.WU Y P.2010.Local government,rent seeking,and industrial policy[M]//WU Y P,WU D R.Rent Seeking and Industrial Development in China.Beijing:The Commercial Press.(in Chinese) 谢地，荣莹，叶子祺.2023.积累体制、调节方式与利益主体关系——马克思主义地租理论的视角[J].经济学动态，(8):31-43.XIE D,RONG Y,YE Z Q.2023.Accumulation systems,regulation and relations of interest subject—From the perspective of Marx's theory of land rent[J].Economic Perspectives,(8):31-43.(in Chinese) 谢富胜，王松，李直.2021.当代国外马克思主义城市地租理论：研究进展与前景展望 [J].中国人民大学学报，35(6):102-114.XIE F S,WANG S,LI Z.2021.A Review of the theories on urban land rent in contemporary western marxism[J].Journal of Renmin University of China,35(6):102-114.(in Chinese) 严瑞珍，龚道广，周志祥，等.1990.中国工农业产品价格剪刀差的现状、发展趋势及对策[J].经济研究，(2):64-70.YAN R Z,GONG D G,ZHOU Z X,et al.1990.The current situation,development trends,and countermeasures of the price scissor gap of Chinese industrial and agricultural products[J].Economic Research Journal,(2):64-70.(in Chinese) 严瑞珍，龚道广，周志祥，等.1998.中国工农业产品价格剪刀差[M].北京：中国人民大学出版社.YAN R Z,GONG D G,ZHOU Z X,et al.1998.The price scissors of industrial and agricultural products in China[M].Beijing:China Renmin University Press.(in Chinese) 余超.2022.租金、制度与经济增长：一个马克思主义分析框架[J].经济纵横，(11):24-32.YU C.2022.Rent,institution and economic growth:A Marxist framework of analysis[J].Economic Review Journal,(11):24-32.(in Chinese) 余超.2023.全球视野下的租金与经济发展——基于马克思主义经济学的理论与实证分析[D].北京：中国人民大学.YU C.2023.Rent and economic development in a global perspective—Theoretical and empirical analysis based on Marxist economics[D].Beijing:Renmin University of China.(in Chinese) 赵峰.2004.马克思的增长理论[J].政治经济学评论，(2):20-48.ZHAO F.2004.Marx's growth theory[J].China Review of Political Economy,(2):20-48.(in Chinese) 赵燕菁.2014.土地财政：历史、逻辑与抉择[J].城市发展研究，21(1):1-13.ZHAO Y J.2014.Land finance in China:History,logic and choices[J].Urban Development Studies,21(1):1-13.(in Chinese) AALBERS M B.2017.The variegated financialization of housing[J].International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,41(4):542-554. AMIN S.2012.The surplus in monopoly capitalism and the imperialist rent[J].Monthly Review,64(3):78. DOS SANTOS T.1970.The structure of dependence[J].The American Economic Review,60(2):231-236. FERNANDEZ R,AALBERS M B.2016.Financialization and housing:Between globalization and varieties of capitalism[J].Competition & Change,20(2):71-88. HAILA A.1990.The theory of land rent at the crossroads[J].Environment and Planning D:Society and Space,8(3):275-296. HARVEY D.1974.Class-monopoly rent,finance capital and the urban revolution[J].Regional Studies,8(3/4):239-255. HARVEY D.1982.The limits to capital[M].Chicago:University of Chicago Press. HARVEY D.2012.The urban roots of the financial crisis:Reclaiming the city for anti-capitalist struggle[J].Socialist Register,48:1-35. HARVEY D.2018.Marx,capital,and the madness of economic reason[M].New York:Oxford University Press. HIGGINBOTTOM A.2014.‘Imperialist rent’ in practice and theory[J].Globalizations,11(1):23-33. KR??TKE S.1992.Urban land rent and real estate markets in the process of social restructuring:The case of Germany[J].Environment and Planning D:Society and Space,10(3):245-264. MANDEL E.1999.Late capitalism[M].London:Verso. MASSEY D.1977.The Analysis of Capitalist Landownership[J].International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,1(1/3):404-424. MASSEY D B,CATALANO A.1978.Capital and land:Landownership by capital in great Britain[M].London:Edward Arnold. SCOTT A J.1980.The urban land nexus and the state[M].London:Pion Limited.
• (1)更详细的模型论证可以参见余超(2022,2023)。 (2)更详细的模型论证可以参见余超(2022,2023)。 (3)巴罗·巴兰的这一观点实际上已经认识到政府对垄断租金的追逐与有效率的社会产权结构之间的持久冲突,从而在某种意义上与新制度经济学“诺思悖论”的理论内核达成了一致。关于“诺思悖论”的理论观点,参见道格拉斯·诺思([1981]1994)。 (4)其他学者同样指出,国际生产价格和平均利润率的形成面临众多阻碍,伊曼纽尔假设利润率在世界范围内可以实现平均化,这违背了马克思关于国际贸易中会形成超额利润的观点,从而导致国际价值转移途径的缺失,参见齐昊(2008)。 (5)统计数据显示,当时国际汽车工业的平均利润率为10%左右,而中国汽车行业的利润率为30%～60%,参见李春林和天舒(1998)。