HE Zhaopeng;YUAN Hanzheng;XIAO Chang;

• 1:School of Economics
• 2:Central University of Finance and Economics

Abstract：

Against the backdrop of China's impeded economic circulation, characterized by insufficient domestic demand, this article based on the practice of the socialist market economy, critically draws on Marxist theory of “Three-circuit” of capital to construct a theoretical framework for analyzing contemporary China's economic circulation: the “Three-circuit” of the Chinese national economy with its distinct characteristics. The core characteristic lies in the institutional constraints and strategic guidance imposed by the socialist public ownership of the means of production on the profitability-seeking nature of capital, with the entire national economic circulation serving the purposes of socialist production. Utilizing this framework to analyze China's economic practice across three phases since the tax-sharing system reform, this paper reveals that excessive reliance on the “secondary circulation” and neglect of the “tertiary circulation” are underlying causes of insufficient domestic demand. Consequently, this article proposes a reform strategy of “dual transformation”: on the one hand, increase investment in scientific and technological innovation and people's livelihood development represented by affordable housing to change the mode of economic development; on the other hand, coordinate and advance related institutional reforms, transform the incentive and constraint mechanisms of local government behavior, while appropriately retaining the proactive role of local governments in conducting infrastructure investment and buffering economic fluctuations

Key Words： insufficient domestic demand;the theory of “Three-circuit” of capital;the theory of the “Three-circuit” of the Chinese national economy with its distinct characteristics;“Dual transformation”

Abstract:

Keywords:

Foundation: 国家社会科学基金重大项目“畅通国民经济循环的理论基础和制度设计研究”(项目批准号24ZDA014)、国家社会科学基金重点项目“实施扩大内需战略同深化供给侧结构性改革有机结合的重大举措研究”(项目批准号23AZD016)的支持

Authors: HE Zhaopeng;YUAN Hanzheng;XIAO Chang;

References：

• 大卫·哈维.2017.资本的限度[M].张寅，译.北京：中信出版社.(original language) HARVEY D.1982.The limits to capital[M].Oxford:Basil Blackwell. 大卫·哈维.2024.政治经济学批判大纲新解[M].张义修，译.北京：中信出版集团：444,448.(original language) HARVEY D.2023.A Companion to Marx's grundrisse[M].London:Verso. 戴维·哈维.2019.新帝国主义[M].付克新，译.北京：中国人民大学出版社.(original language) HARVEY D.2004.The new imperialism[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press. 郭克莎.2024.统筹扩大内需和深化供给侧结构性改革的深层逻辑[J].中国社会科学，(6):4-11.GUO K S.2024.Coordinating the expansion of domestic demand and the deepening of supply-side structural reform:The underlying logic[J].Social Sciences in China,(6):4-11.(in Chinese) 韩雷，彭思倩，何召鹏.2022.畅通国内大循环的内在逻辑与实现路径——基于马克思主义资本三级循环理论[J].经济纵横，(6):21-29.HAN L,PENG S Q,HE Z P.2022.Smooth the domestic cycle:Internal logic and realization path—Based on marxist theory of three-stage capital circulation[J].Economic Review Journal,(6):21-29.(in Chinese) 韩喜平，马丽娟.2024.马克思经济循环理论与构建新发展格局[J].马克思主义与现实，(5):101-110,203-204.HAN X P,MA L J.2024.Marx's economic cycle theory:Forging a new development dynamic[J].Marxism & Reality,(5):101-110,203-204.(in Chinese) 何召鹏.2022.“国民共进”的政治经济学分析[J].政治经济学评论，13(2):148-163.HE Z P.2022.The political economy analysis of “the State advances as the private sector advances”[J].China Review of Political Economy,13(2):148-163.(in Chinese) 何召鹏.2025.价值理论的空间政治经济学分析[J].政治经济学评论，16(2):211-224.HE Z P.2025.Spatial political economy analysis of value theory[J].China Review of Political Economy,16(2):211-224.(in Chinese) 何召鹏，肖畅.2025.中国特色基础设施建设的政治经济学分析：理论逻辑与转型发展[J].教学与研究，(5):102-114.HE Z P,XIAO C.2025.Political-economic analysis of infrastructure development with Chinese Characteristics:Theoretical logic and transformation pathways[J].Teaching and Research,(5):102-114.(in Chinese) 江小涓，孟丽君.2021.内循环为主、外循环赋能与更高水平双循环——国际经验与中国实践[J].管理世界，37(1):1-18.JIANG X J,MENG L J.2021.Mainly inner circulation,outer circulation empowerment and higher level double circulation:International experience and Chinese practice[J].Journal of Management World,37(1):1-18.(in Chinese) 蒋震.2014.工业化水平、地方政府努力与土地财政：对中国土地财政的一个分析视角[J].中国工业经济，(10):33-45.JIANG Z.2014.Industrialization,local government efforts and land finance:A perspective of land finance in China[J].China Industrial Economics,(10):33-45.(in Chinese) 李建伟.2018.中国经济增长四十年回顾与展望[J].管理世界，34(10):11-23.LI J W.2018.Retrospect and prospect of China's forty years of economic growth[J].Journal of Management World,34(10):11-23.(in Chinese) 李克强.2011.大规模实施保障性安居工程逐步完善住房政策和供应体系[J].求是，(8):3-8. 李自若，杨汝岱，黄桂田.2022.内贸成本、外贸成本与畅通国内大循环[J].中国工业经济，(2):61-79.LI Z R,YANG R D,HUANG G T.2022.Intra-national trade costs,international trade costs and the promotion of the domestic circulation of China[J].China Industrial Economics,(2):61-79.(in Chinese) 林岗.1987.论“生产力决定生产关系”的原理——兼析生产资料全民所有制的结构和[J].哲学研究，(4):28-38.LIN G.1987.On the principle of “productive forces determining production relations”:With analysis of the structure of public ownership of means of production[J].Philosophical Research,(4):28-38.(in Chinese) 刘海建，胡化广.2023.畅通国民经济循环与劳动力就业——基于流通标准一体化视角的研究[J].数量经济技术经济研究，40(10):51-70.LIU H J,HU H G.2023.Smooth national economic cycle and employment of labor:Based on the perspective of integration of circulation standards[J].The Journal of Quantitative & Technical Economics,40(10):51-70.(in Chinese) 马克思，恩格斯.1974.马克思恩格斯全集(第26卷第2册)[M].北京：人民出版社. 马克思，恩格斯.2012.马克思恩格斯选集(第二卷)[M].北京：人民出版社. 马克思，恩格斯.2021.马克思恩格斯文集(第5卷)[M].中共中央马克思恩格斯列宁斯大林著作编译局，译.北京：人民出版社. 孟捷，吴丰华.2020.制度-垄断地租与中国地方政府竞争：一个马克思主义分析框架[J].开放时代，(2):160-179.MENG J,WU F H.2020.The institution-monopoly rent and competition between local governments in China:A marxist framework of analysis[J].Open Times,(2):160-179.(in Chinese) 田野，倪红福，夏杰长.2024.国内国际经济循环、产业结构与劳动收入份额变动[J].世界经济，47(2):3-31.TIAN Y,NI H F,XIA J C.2024.Domestic and international economic cycles,industrial structure and changes in the aggregate share of Labour Income[J].The Journal of World Economy,47(2):3-31.(in Chinese) 王晋斌，厉妍彤.2021.论中国特色社会主义金融发展与经济增长理论——中国金融发展与经济增长关系的政治经济学[J].政治经济学评论，12(1):203-219.WANG J B,LI Y T.2021.On the financial development and economic growth theory of socialism with Chinese characteristics:Political economy of the relation between financial development and economic growth in China[J].China Review of Political Economy,12(1):203-219.(in Chinese) 王媛.2013.我国地方政府经营城市的战略转变——基于地级市面板数据的经验证据[J].经济学家，(11):76-85.WANG Y.2013.Strategic transformation of managing a city for local government—Empirical evidence based on city panel data[J].Economist,(11):76-85.(in Chinese) 王智强，程恩富.2024.开放经济社会再生产视角下经济循环与经济增长研究[J].经济研究，59(7):188-208.WANG Z Q,CHENG E F.2024.A study on economic circulation and economic growth from the perspective of reproduction in an open economy[J].Economic Research Journal,59(7):188-208.(in Chinese) 温兴祥.2025.城市保障性住房获取对农业转移人口家庭消费的影响[J].中国农村观察，(2):50-68.WEN X X.2025.The effect of access to urban affordable housing on household consumption of rural migrant workers[J].China Rural Survey,(2):50-68.(in Chinese) 郗戈.2023.“驾驭资本”与中国式现代化的理论思考[J].中国社会科学，(12):4-18,199.XI G.2023.A theoretical analysis of “Harnessing capital” and Chinese modernization[J].Social Sciences in China,(12):4-18,199.(in Chinese) 习近平.2025.习近平经济文选(第1卷)[M].北京：中央文献出版社. 谢富胜，高岭，谢佩瑜.2019.全球生产网络视角的供给侧结构性改革——基于政治经济学的理论逻辑和经验证据[J].管理世界，35(11):89-101,118.XIE F S,GAO L,XIE P Y.2019.The supply-side structural reform in the perspective of global production network:Based on the theory of political economy and evidence[J].Journal of Management World,35(11):89-101,118.(in Chinese) 谢富胜，匡晓璐.2022.以问题为导向构建新发展格局[J].中国社会科学，(6):161-180,208.XIE F S,KUANG X L.2022.Building a new development pattern with a problem-oriented approach[J].Social Sciences in China,(6):161-180,208.(in Chinese) 徐志向，丁任重，张敏.2021.马克思社会再生产理论视阈下中国经济“双循环”新发展格局研究[J].政治经济学评论，12(5):40-63.XU Z X,DING R Z,ZHANG M.2021.Research on the new development pattern of China's economic “Dual Circulation” from the perspective of Marx's social reproduction theory[J].China Review of Political Economy,12(5):40-63.(in Chinese) 杨雪锋，史晋川.2010.地根经济视角下土地政策反周期调节的机理分析[J].经济理论与经济管理，(6):5-11.YANG X F,SHI J C.2010.Analysis of functioning mechanism of land policy and macroeconomic adjustment from the theory of land-regulated economy[J].Economic Theory and Business Management,(6):5-11.(in Chinese) 余泳泽，胡山，杨飞.2022.国内大循环的障碍：区域市场分割的效率损失[J].中国工业经济，(12):108-126.YU Y Z,HU S,YANG F.2022.The barrier to domestic economic cycle:Efficiency loss of regional market segmentation[J].China Industrial Economics,(12):108-126.(in Chinese) 张平，刘霞辉.2011.城市化、财政扩张与经济增长[J].经济研究，(11):4-20.ZHANG P,LIU X H.2011.Urbanization,fiscal expansion and economic growth[J].Economic Research Journal,(11):4-20.(in Chinese) 张宇.2016.论公有制与市场经济的有机结合[J].经济研究，51(6):4-16.ZHANG Y.2016.On the organic combination of public ownership and market economy[J].Economic Research Journal,51(6):4-16.(in Chinese) 赵景龙.2025.低空经济高质量发展：内涵特征、约束条件与突破路径[J].当代经济研究，(4):27-42.ZHAO J L.2025.High-quality development of low-altitude economy:Connotation characteristics,constraints and breakthrough paths[J].Contemporary Economic Research,(4):27-42.(in Chinese) 中国国际经济交流中心课题组.2024.我国消费领域面临的障碍与应对[J].全球化，(2):19-28.Research Group of China Center for International Economic Exchanges.2024.Obstacles and responses faced by China's consumption sector[J].Globalization,(2):19-28.(in Chinese) 周世愚.2021.地方政府债务风险：理论分析与经验事实[J].管理世界，37(10):128-137.ZHOU S Y.2021.Local government debt risk:Theoretical analysis and empirical facts[J].Journal of Management World,37(10):128-137.(in Chinese) HARVEY D.1978.The urban process under capitalism:A framework for analysis[J].International Journal of Urban and Regional Research,2(1/3):101-131.
• (1)新华社.2024-12-12.中央经济工作会议在北京举行习近平发表重要讲话.https://www.gov.cn/yaowen/liebiao/202412/content_6992258.htm。 (2)“在兰开夏郡,棉纺织工厂占据统治地位,它们在英格兰、威尔士、苏格兰和爱尔兰的所有同类工厂占45.2%,占纱锭总数的83.3%,占蒸汽织机总数的81.4%,占棉纺织厂蒸汽劳动总数的72.6%,占雇佣职工总数的58.2%。”参见马克思和恩格斯(2021,p.482)。 (3)“价值丧失”:丧失了社会意义的抽象劳动。参见哈维([1982]2017,p.315)。 (4)“过度积累”:资本缺乏盈利性的投资途径而被迫堆积。参见哈维([2004]2019,p.82)。 (5)美国私人国内总投资(固定投资,住宅)于2005年开始下降,一直持续到2011年左右;私人国内总投资(固定资本,非住宅)于2008年开始下降。这两项投资在危机之前都呈不断上升态势。数据来源于CEIC数据库。 (6)其中制造业部门失业率13.00%,金融部门失业率6.6%。数据来源于CEIC数据库。 (7)中华人民共和国工业和信息化部.2024-12-09.https://wap.miit.gov.cn/xwfb/mtbd/wzbd/art/2024/art_c201630dc5c44ab8adbb2631d4f8e4d4.html。 (8)求是网.2022-07-11.突破难题、攀登高峰,国有企业要做“排头兵”.http://www.qstheory.cn/zhuanqu/2022-07/11/c_1128820356.htm。 (9)哈维举了一个皮鞋和铁路的例子来说明这种不匹配:卖不出去的皮鞋无法直接投入到铁路的生产,需要先将这种过剩“货币化”,而后才能引导资本流入“次级循环”。参见哈维([1982]2017,p.419)。 (10)之所以将中国经济循环第三阶段(2016年至今)划在供给侧结构性改革之后,原因是:内需不足对经济发展的制约,虽然基本上是从高速增长阶段结束之后(2010年左右)就开始的,但以结构性、长期性、阶段性视角对待内需问题(郭克莎,2024),以供给结构优化来解决内需问题却是在供给侧结构性改革中提出的,特别是2016年中央经济工作会议召开之后才开始全面贯彻落实。其中有两方面的供给需要得到重点优化:一是一般产品供给质量提升,以匹配个性多样化消费需求,这需要创新;二是公共服务供给增加,以降低居民消费不确定性。两方面问题解决的关键是要重视“非物质生产条件”在我国经济循环中的重要作用。这是供给侧结构性改革之后我国经济循环相比于前两阶段呈现不同样态的关键因素。 (11)根据李建伟(2018)的测算,2007年,出口占我国最终消费与基础需求的比率分别为68.68%和40.72%。 (12)根据张平和刘霞辉(2011)的测算,2007—2009年,全国城建资金中土地出让金分别占比35.04%、37.49%和39.18%。 (13)2007—2011,货物和服务净出口对我国GDP的贡献率分别为7.8%、2.7%、-42.8%、-10.8%、-6.8%,数据来自国家统计局。 (14)中华人民共和国中央人民政府.2008-11-10.https://www.gov.cn/jrzg/2008-11/10/content_1143810.htm。 (15)中国人民银行.2009-03-23.http://www.pbc.gov.cn/goutongjiaoliu/113456/113469/2879576/index.html。 (16)根据周世愚(2021),2009年我国地方政府性债务余额增速达到61.92%的历史新高。其中,地方融资平台公司贷款余额为7.38万亿元,同比增长70.4%。 (17)中华人民共和国中央人民政府.2008-11-10.https://www.gov.cn/jrzg/2008-11/10/content_1143810.htm。 (18)华安证券.2024-01-17.2024年我国保障性住房专题报告.https://m.vzkoo.com/read/20240117dcb08a9e5bb9edaa58e778da.html。 (19)根据CEIC数据库,2016年中国、英国、美国、德国四国政府教育支出占国内生产总值的百分比分别为4.2%、5.2%、4.7%、4.6%,研发支出占国内生产总值的百分比分别为2.1%、2.3%、2.8%、2.9%。 (20)习近平主持召开中央财经领导小组第十一次会议.2015-11-10.https://www.xinhuanet.com//politics/2015-11/10/c_1117099915.htm。 (21)中央经济工作会议在北京举行习近平李克强作重要讲话.2016-12-16.https://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2016-12/16/content_5149018.htm。 (22)中华人民共和国中央人民政府.2024-09-14.https://www.gov.cn/lianbo/bumen/202409/content_6974986.htm#。 (23)数据来自国家统计局,作者计算而成。2013年开始,土地出让收入算在政府性基金收入中;地方财政收入指的是一般公共预算收入。 (24)根据中国国际经济交流中心课题组(2024),截至2022年,个人住房贷款占个人消费贷款近70%,住户贷款余额占可支配收入的比重由2015年的66.76%上升到2021年的104.3%。受这些因素影响,2023年居民部门杠杆率升至63.5%,较2022年上升1.3个百分点。