An Analysis of Empirical Research on the Labor Theory of Value Using Input-Output Tables
TAO Weiqun;
Abstract:
For the empirical research on the labor theory of value using input-output tables, this paper conducts a relatively systematic and comprehensive study, aiming to basically form a logicalclosed loop so as to deepen and enrich the empirical research on the theory. The value magnitude defined in Marx's labor theory of value—the socially necessary labor time is a unity of the “first meaning” and the “second meaning”. The socially necessary labor time of the “second meaning” can only be established through the realization of social reproduction. Therefore, the empirical research on the labor theory of value must be integrated with the realization of social reproduction to be complete. Such empirical research cannot bypass Marx's social reproduction theory on the composition of the product value of the means of production and the means of consumption in the context of realizing the social reproduction with two major categories. Such empirical research by use of the input-output table is necessary and possible to expand the scope of the two major categories of goods, namely means of production and means of consumption, to include service goods, and it should be in the context of social reproduction with fixed capital occupation and depreciation in reality. Under the value system and the price system, the realization of social reproduction will make social reproduction “productive”. Therefore, if the assumption that “the total amount of surplus value is equal to the total amount of profit” is followed, a theoretical relationship between the value and price of two commodities of means of production and means of consumption is obtained, which is namely “the price of a unit commodity of means of production and means of consumption is equal to its value”. The paper introduces the concept of joint production and uses the value-based input-output tables to calculate the price composition of products of means of production and means of consumption, so as to map the input-occupation-output of each industrial sector to produce the two “pure products” of means of production and means of consumption. This approach can be regarded as corresponding to the preparation of input-output tables using the indirect derivation method—UV table method. By respectively applying the sector technology assumption and the product technology assumption, a certain linear transformation is carried out on the broad input, that is, the price composition of the output of each industrial sector, converting it into the price composition of the two “pure products” of means of production and means of consumption. Given that the conclusion can be reached that “the price of a unit commodity of means of production and means of consumption is equal to its value”, the different calculation results of the product price composition of the two “pure products” obtained under the two technical assumptions using input-output tables can all be regarded as the empirical research results of the labor theory of value.
Key Words: empirical research on the labor theory of value;the socially necessary labor time;social reproduction;joint production;UV table method
Foundation:
Authors: TAO Weiqun;
References:
- 陈宝林.2005.最优化理论与算法[M].2版.北京:清华大学出版社.Chen B L.2005.Optimization theory and algorithms[M].2nd ed.Beijing:Tsinghua University Press.(in Chinese)
- 程恩富,冯金华,马艳.2012.现代政治经济学新编[M].2版.上海:上海财经大学出版社.Cheng E F,Feng J H,Ma Y.2012.Modern political economics[M].2nd ed.Shanghai:Shanghai University of Finance & Economics Press.(in Chinese)
- 冯金华.2012.一般均衡理论的价值基础[J].经济研究,47(1):31-41.Feng J H.2012.The value foundation of general equilibrium theory[J].Economic ResearchJournal,47(1):31-41.(in Chinese)
- 林岗.2005.关于社会必要劳动时间以及劳动生产率与价值量关系问题的探讨[J].教学与研究,(7):52-58.Lin G.2005.Some propositions on socially necessary labor and the relation between labor productivity and magnitude of value[J].Teaching and Research,(7):52-58.(in Chinese)
- 刘起运,陈璋,苏汝劼.2020.投入产出分析[M].3版.北京:中国人民大学出版社.Liu Q Y,Chen Z,Su R J.2020.Input-output analysis[M].3rd ed.Beijing:China Renmin University Press.(in Chinese)
- 刘新建,何泽德,杨茜.2022.中国两大部类结构特征及其在新发展格局中的作用——基于两部类投入产出数据的分析[J].当代经济研究,(4):84-97.Liu X J,He Z D,Yang Q.2022.Structural characteristics of China's two major categories and their role in the new development pattern—analysis based on the input-output table[J].Contemporary Economic Research,(4):84-97.(in Chinese)
- 马克思.2004.资本论:第1卷[M].中共中央马克思恩格斯列宁斯大林著作编译局,译.2版.北京:人民出版社.
- 裴宏,潘东奇.2024.马克思还是李嘉图——对劳动价值论定量检验方法的一个温和批评[J].政治经济学季刊,3(3):98-133.Pei H,Pan D Q.2024.Marx or Ricardo?—A mild critique on the quantitative testing of the labor theory of value[J].Political Economy Quarterly,3(3):98-133.(in Chinese)
- 陶为群.2025.有折旧的社会再生产动态投入占用产出分析——两大部类总资本增殖与扩大的解析解[M]//《政治经济学报》第34卷.天津:天津人民出版社:159-177.Tao W Q.2025.Dynamic input-occupancy-output analysis of social reproduction with depreciation—analytical solution for appreciation and expansion of total capital of the two major departments[M]//The Chinese Journal of Political Economy,Vol.34.Tianjin:Tianjin People's Publishing House:159-177.(in Chinese)
- 陶为群.2026.拓展的马克思社会再生产——理论阐释与数理分析[M].北京:经济科学出版社.Tao W Q.2026.Extended Marxist social reproduction—theoretical interpretation and mathematical analysis[M].Beijing:Economic Science Press.(in Chinese)
- 陶为群,陶川.2010.两大部类产品价值构成的约束极大似然估计[J].西安财经学院学报,23(4):72-77.Tao W Q,Tao C.2010.Constrained maximum likelihood estimation to the value composition of the product of two major social production departments[J].Journal of Xi'an University of Finance and Economics,23(4):72-77.(in Chinese)
- 藤森赖明,李帮喜.2014.马克思经济学与数理分析[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社.Fujimori Y,Li B X.2014.Marxian economics and mathematical analysis[M].Beijing:Social Sciences Academic Press.(in Chinese)
- 赵峰,赵翌辰,李帮喜.2017.马克思两大部类模型与中国经济的宏观结构:一个经验研究[J].中国人民大学学报,31(2):73-81.Zhao F,Zhao Y C,Li B X.2017.Marxian two-sector reproduction schema and Chinese macroeconomic structures:an empirical investigation[J].Journal of Renmin University of China,31(2):73-81.(in Chinese)
- 赵立.2023.马克思主义科学方法的核心要旨——基于马克思恩格斯对孔德实证主义的批判[J].湖南科技大学学报(社会科学版),26(2):142-148.Zhao L.2023.The core tenets of Marxist scientific method:based on Marx and Engels' critique of Comte's positivism[J].Journal of Hunan University of Science and Technology (Social Science Edition),26(2):142-148.(in Chinese)
- empirical research on the labor theory of value
- the socially necessary labor time
- social reproduction
- joint production
- UV table method